Fall into Love 2026

Garage Sale Mysteries: Murder Takes the Stage

Jennifer Shannon's true-crime book club stages a Lizzie Borden reenactment, and one of the members doesn't survive the evening.

PremieredSat · Sept 19 · 8/7c

Looks logged4

As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. About our links

Played by Lori Loughlin · 3 changes

Jennifer Shannon

Garage sale pro and amateur sleuth. Airy floral blouses with a chunky gold chain, plus one very elaborate costume.

Change 01 · 4 pieces

Back at her antiques shop, surrounded by finds.

Change 02 · 2 pieces

Piecing the clues together.

Change 03 · 3 pieces

The book club's Lizzie Borden reenactment: ivory satin, gold embroidery, and ruffles.

Played by Sarah Strange · 1 changes

Her best friend with a rockabilly streak: gingham, embroidered swallows, and a red lip.

Change 01 · 3 pieces

Keeping an eye on things at the shop.